This paper investigated the fretting failure of axial thrust steel bearings as per ASTM 4170 in the presence of anti-fretting pastes used in process industries. The pastes were differentiated based on the content of additives in them. The results indicated that the paste containing the additive package of copper, molybdenum disulfide, and graphite exhibited excellent anti-fretting properties (75–80% less bearing race mass loss) as compared with other lubricating pastes that contained only graphite/molybdenum disulfide and nickel as primary additives. There was less surface damage to the bearing races in the lubricating paste containing copper, graphite, and molybdenum disulfide. The machine vision images of the false brinelling indicated that the average area of false brinelling on the bearing races with the paste containing copper, molybdenum disulfide, and graphite was 2.537 ± 0.623 mm 2, while that of the other pastes containing graphite/molybdenum disulfide and nickel as primary additives were 4.504 ± 0.566 mm 2 and 4.914 ± 0.621 mm 2, respectively, indicating 50% less false brinelling area in the paste containing copper, molybdenum disulfide, and graphite as compared with the paste containing graphite/molybdenum disulfide and nickel. An asymmetric wear pattern was also observed in the thrust bearings used during the tribo test. Surface characterizations indicated the formation of wear debris, plastic deformations, and surface cracks during the tribo tests. The physico-chemical properties of the lubricating pastes such as the viscosity and work penetration properties played an important role in controlling the failure of the bearings due to fretting.