The development of high-performance lubricants under extreme pressure (EP) is of great significance for reducing energy waste and protecting ecology in heavy industries such as aerospace, large machinery, and so on. Sulfurized isobutylene (SIB) has been explored as one of the most effective EP additives for oil-based lubricants and delivered promising friction-reducing performance. However, the excessive corrosion caused by SIB on the metal surface seriously reduces the instrument’s lifetime and hinders its extensive practical application. Herein, we develop stearic acid-modified TiO2 nanoparticles (SA-TiO2) as a lubricant additive to improve the EP lubrication performance of obtained composite lubricant (CL). During EP friction, the SA-TiO2 can tune the interfacial structure of tribopair and form a high-strength nano-ceramic film to improve tribological performance. Meanwhile, the SA-TiO2 can also compensate for the high wear caused by SIB, thus significantly enhancing the antiwear, friction reduction, and EP properties by 27%, 20%, and 25%, respectively, when compared with the traditional lubricant (TL) obtained by only SIB. Benefiting from the above synergistic effects, the CL can significantly lower the SIB contents while maintaining high EP performance (4900 N weld load). These findings demonstrate a promising eco-friendly lubricant and provide new insights into the mechanism study for EP lubrication. © 2017 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.